Template:Cabuyao City
A child template of {{City of Cabuyao}}. I don't see any reason not to merge the two since the info in this template is already found in the other one. Unnecessary and redundant. Xeltran (talk) 11:07, 26 November 2012 (UTC)
- Update: This is a re-listing of the template since the previous deletion nomination did not result to a consensus. Xeltran (talk) 08:52, 27 November 2012 (UTC)
- I agree that it would be more logical to merge this template into {{City of Cabuyao}}, because they relate to the same place. — Martin (MSGJ · talk) 15:52, 26 November 2012 (UTC)
- This issue has already been discussed before. This template only shows all the barangays unlike the other {{City of Cabuyao}} which is more broad. Othanwiki2009 (T)
- Keep. Same with {{Legislative districts of Valenzuela City}} in which all of Valenzuela's barangays are separated from {{Valenzuela City}} template. Othanwiki2009 (T)
- Merge. There is no reason to add a few more barangay links to {{City of Cabuyao}}, which should be cleaned up as well (too many incidental links). -- P 1 9 9 ✉ 22:32, 28 November 2012 (UTC)
- All of Cabuyao's barangays have their own links, compared to Valenzuela's. If the two templates should be merged, {{Valenzuela City}} and {{Legislative districts of Valenzuela City}} should be merged too. Othanwiki2009 (T)
- Merge Redundant and unnecessary, in fact articles linked to template should be AfDed, as they all fail the notability test. Small villages of a tiny little unknown provincial town. All but one barangay should be deleted, IMO the industrial village of Canlubang is the only notable place worthy of a WP article. --RioHondo (talk) 02:26, 30 November 2012 (UTC)
- I quote "Small villages of a tiny little unknown provincial town", excuse me, are you pertaining to Cabuyao? FYI, Cabuyao is a First Class Component City, and before it became a city, it was the richest Municipality of the Philippines. If you want to delete all the articles related to Cabuyao for your so many reasons, go on! But don't pertain Cabuyao into a tiny little unknown provincial town. Why don't you try to improve Canlubang's article here in WP if you're saying that it is the ONLY notable place worthy of a WP article?? Are you underestimating Cabuyao's barangays??? Cabuyao is dubbed as an Entrepreneurial and Industrial City because of its industrial barangays that you're pertaining to small villages. Happy merging and deleting articles!! -Othanwiki2009 (T)
-
- No, i am referring to the "city" of Tabuk. In a country where even the smallest towns dominated by farmlands and cows are labelled as "cities" (thanks to its influential congressman and mayor with good connections to the president), the city tagging isn't and shouldn't always be relied upon as indication of progress or even, notability. Heck, even the laidback Sipalay and remote Bayugan or even the NPA-infested Guihulngan are labelled as cities these days. As for the "richest municipality" or LGU (thank goodness we had that deleted), if anyone ever believes that, it only means you have a mayor to thank for, for keeping corruption at a minimum and declaring its income honestly cos more populated towns with closer proximity to the metropolis don't get that like Cainta and San Pedro, Laguna. I bet you Barangay Balibago in Santa Rosa, Laguna is at least 10 times more notable than all of your Cabuyao barangays combined, and yet even that doesn't have its own article. --RioHondo (talk) 05:17, 30 November 2012 (UTC)
- "City" tagging is not the main topic for this discussion, you're out of topic. Anyway, we're not discussing for which barangay or village should be notable to have a WP article, you even mentioned Balibago which you said 10 times more notable than all of Cabuyao's barangays, are you trying to say that Balibago (if it has an article) is more notable than the whole Cabuyao article? Why don't you list down all small villages which you think are notable and request to have an article in WP?? You know, it's in the content that makes an article notable! All municipalities in the Philippines have articles in WP, do you think all of their articles have notability? Especially the small ones, remote areas, fourth or fifth class towns?? What's the difference between Mamatid's article (Cabuyao's most populated barangay) and El Salvador, Misamis Oriental's article when it comes to notability?? El Salvador is a city in Misamis Occidental, its population is 47,000+ in which I think is lower than the population of Mamatid, an urban barangay, of 50,000+ people. Mamatid is very progressive, it's income and population is already qualified for a municipality status, it is even more progressive than other municipalities existing. Is it enough already for Mamatid to have an article here? Or it is still lacking for notability? -Othanwiki2009 (T)
- AFAIK, this conversation only became off topic when someone started saying Bacuyao is the Entrepreneurial and achuchuchu City, 1st class City-BS that deserves this many templates. That's city tagging for you. All these cities and municipalities are incorporated places and they belong to the third-level administrative country subdivision which are all considered notable by default. Mamati or whatever you call your little village and all the rest of the barangays, however, aren't. Unless they are real prominent and backed up by many solid sources from the internet that would prove their significance (e.g, economic), notability or prominence, then they're valid as separate articles. But Manati, Achuchu-I and Achuchu-II? If you ask me, the only real notable barangays in Laguna would be Canlubang, Balibago, Pansol and maybe Mamplasan. All the rest are forgettable. But who knows? the largest barangay of each city (population-wise) could be an exception?--RioHondo (talk) 14:13, 30 November 2012 (UTC)
- "City" tagging is not the main topic for this discussion, you're out of topic. Anyway, we're not discussing for which barangay or village should be notable to have a WP article, you even mentioned Balibago which you said 10 times more notable than all of Cabuyao's barangays, are you trying to say that Balibago (if it has an article) is more notable than the whole Cabuyao article? Why don't you list down all small villages which you think are notable and request to have an article in WP?? You know, it's in the content that makes an article notable! All municipalities in the Philippines have articles in WP, do you think all of their articles have notability? Especially the small ones, remote areas, fourth or fifth class towns?? What's the difference between Mamatid's article (Cabuyao's most populated barangay) and El Salvador, Misamis Oriental's article when it comes to notability?? El Salvador is a city in Misamis Occidental, its population is 47,000+ in which I think is lower than the population of Mamatid, an urban barangay, of 50,000+ people. Mamatid is very progressive, it's income and population is already qualified for a municipality status, it is even more progressive than other municipalities existing. Is it enough already for Mamatid to have an article here? Or it is still lacking for notability? -Othanwiki2009 (T)
- No, i am referring to the "city" of Tabuk. In a country where even the smallest towns dominated by farmlands and cows are labelled as "cities" (thanks to its influential congressman and mayor with good connections to the president), the city tagging isn't and shouldn't always be relied upon as indication of progress or even, notability. Heck, even the laidback Sipalay and remote Bayugan or even the NPA-infested Guihulngan are labelled as cities these days. As for the "richest municipality" or LGU (thank goodness we had that deleted), if anyone ever believes that, it only means you have a mayor to thank for, for keeping corruption at a minimum and declaring its income honestly cos more populated towns with closer proximity to the metropolis don't get that like Cainta and San Pedro, Laguna. I bet you Barangay Balibago in Santa Rosa, Laguna is at least 10 times more notable than all of your Cabuyao barangays combined, and yet even that doesn't have its own article. --RioHondo (talk) 05:17, 30 November 2012 (UTC)
- Will you please be careful on your spelling of Cabuyao? and Mamatid?? So simple spelling. "Bacuyao", "Mamatid" or "Manati"??? Don't pretend to be idiot, because I know that you just want to insist that your bet "Balibago", "Canlubang" and others are more popular and notable than all barangays of Cabuyao that is why you spelled them right. -Othanwiki2009 (T)
Anyway, no biggie. Ilan lang 'yan sa mga contributions ko na in-erase ng ilang mga Wikipedians due to some reasons.
